Son and Foe
 
Home » Songbird Reviews  
« previous post     next post »

Songbird Reviews

by Jeremiah Sturgill, posted on July 11, 2007 — No comments, filed under Nonfiction

Everyone should Google their name occasionally; you’d be surprised at what turns up. Today I found a handful of reviews for “Songbird,” my short story published in Jim Baen’s Universe. A number of them were quite flattering, but there was one reality check mixed in with all the rest…

Margaret Fisk had this to say:

Songbird is an amazing story (I almost typed song) with its entirety in the cadence in the echoes of an old man’s thoughts. While not in any way a traditional form, it has power, and a message, and heart.

GUD Magazine had this to say:

My favourite story, which I remember seeing in slush on the Baen Bar, comes from the “Introducing New Authors” slot that’s reserved for up-and-coming authors who haven’t previously broken into professional markets. Jeremiah Sturgill’s “Songbird” is a nicely understated story of a vasya, a singer of the sounds of nature, and a boy who seeks to be his apprentice.

Susanne Warr had this to say:

More of a concept and idea story than an action or adventure story, “Songbird” feels almost like poetry that’s slipped over into prose form. The characterization was very nice, the song concepts were lovely, the imagery was clean and fresh. I can heartily recommend this story.

PamL had this to say:

I really liked this story. It was a song in itself.

David de Beer had this to say:

A very passive but gentle, at times even beautiful, narrative. Sturgill never gives into temptation to try and make this story more than it needs to be, uses no gimmicks to try and liven up the tale, but settles for a quiet, simplistic read that is nevertheless somehow captivating.

Josh (not my brother) had this to say:

This is one of the most beautiful and poetic pieces in the issue. Even though the story is told from a more bitter and cynical perspective, at the end, one’s love for life and the heralding of music and sound in everything we do. A gorgeous work.

von Darkmoor had a mostly negative reaction:

The protagonist is a rather pompous prick and I lose interest in him almost from the beginning. Only the faint hope of what may happen to the second character kept me reading. A quarter of the way into the story, this is my only reason for reading further, the only question the tale teases me with. I’m as tired of the protagonist and his thoughts as he unceasingly claims to be.

Ouch!

Well, as I said above, it was a good reality check (nothing is liked by everyone, after all), and as far as negative reviews go, it’s not too scathing.

I am pretty new with crafting an online persona, and also with communicating extensively with people through e-mail and message boards and so forth. Hopefully this will help prepare me for even harsher criticism later on, and help me hold back from taking it personally and proving how much of a douche I can be (I need all the help I can get with this, as I’ve sometimes proved with S&F.).

As for the positive reviews, they are spectacular. Encouraging barely scratches the surface.

Of course, I don’t know that any of these people would ever have mentioned my story without a promotion offered by Baen’s Universe: bloggers who reviewed the issue within a certain time frame would get links to their blog posted to the magazine’s website.

I’ll take what I can get.

« previous post     next post »

No Comments Yet

You can be the first to comment!

 
 

Leave a comment

 
« previous post   home   next post »